Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Letter to the Editor: Add the Integrity - A Response to Minus the City

Class of 2012

Published: Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Updated: Thursday, February 25, 2010 11:02

I'll be honest; I used to pay absolutely no attention to the Minus the City column written by Mat Nittman and Ben Shope. After reading it the first week of the semester, I wrote it off as nonsense. Things changed when the by-line read BJ 101; the pieces that I originally marked as nonsense were now marked as beyond offensive.

Regardless of the seriousness of the article, the message that the article sends is completely wrong. Essentially, Nittman and Shope claim that Colgate students (and everyone else for that matter) should practice the "oral arts" as often as possible and as diligently as possible in order to be "accomplished" as sexual beings. They go even farther to claim that those that are somewhat "accomplished" in the "oral arts" need more practice in order to be considered satisfactory.

And for women, swallowing is "standard." How disgusting! Their article is not only degrading, but also sends a message that doesn't have a single shred of positive sexuality.

Positive sexuality is something we are struggling to achieve on Colgate's campus. In the aftermath of the Campus Climate Life Survey, it is hard for one to dispute that messages of positive sexuality are needed on this campus in order to establish a more comfortable atmosphere. It is impossible to expect that everyone is going to wake up tomorrow morning and choose abstinence over sleeping with that hot person from class.

However, Colgate faculty and students can choose to start sending messages of positive sexuality that encourages students to approach any sort of intimate relations in a positive, safe and respectable way towards oneself and one's partner.

Nittman and Shope seem to encourage the opposite; their article does not address anything regarding safety or respect. The claims can be interpreted insofar as to say: Always expect to give your one night stand, consistent hook-up or significant other a blow job. Or always expect to receive oral sex even if you don't really want it. It doesn't matter if the message is meant to be a joke; it will still be a message that will leave an impression on a lot of peoples' minds.

I leave you all with a few questions to ponder. If you were Buttercup or Prince Charming, how would you feel about the following?

How would you feel about giving and/or receiving a blowjob in public?

Would you be comfortable with oral sex despite the fact that you know nothing about the other's sexual history (including the possibility that the other person might have an STI)? Where's the condom? Would you use one? Make smart decisions. Practice positive sexuality. Don't do anything when you are questioning the decision or feeling force or pressure from your partner.
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

13 comments

'gate alumnus
Fri Mar 5 2010 19:05
In response to the original article:
While you guys are free to write whatever you like, you should consider that this online paper has a wider circulation than just students. Alumni do occasional take a look at the Maroon News online, as I just did. So I would just urge you to consider if you would still use this medium write what you do given that it may happen across more than just current students.
Anonymous
Mon Mar 1 2010 18:28
This piece is useless. Meanwhile, Shope and Nitmans work is pure art. They are the picasso and van gogh of our time.

Just kidding but seriously.

Anonymous
Mon Mar 1 2010 16:28
I agree with the other poster who said "[p]eople here have absolutely NO sense of humor". None of the supposedly amusing columns in this paper are funny at all.

I don't really care if these nimrods Shope and Nittman had a sex-positive perspective. They could call for a campus-wide weekend rape tournament, for all I care. What really bothers me is that they are banal, sophomoric, and witless. Parody and irony can be really entertaining, but these guys write pure garbage.

Anonymous
Mon Mar 1 2010 13:40
While the BJ 101 article was a little bit crude for my usual sense of humor, I don't think this hyperbolized indictment is all that necessary either. I see way worse humor than those two writing "Minus the City" use when I watch TV.

If, as I suspect the case may be, the writers of "Minus the City" have been pushing the envelope to gain attention and stir up controversy, you're also only succeeding in giving them exactly what they want by publishing such a reactionary article. If you really wanted to enact the positive influence on Colgate that you write about, you would ignore Mat Nittman and Ben Shope entirely, not give them a bigger reader-base on a silver platter! You don't have to deliver your message on their terms (which is what you're doing here by the way). That age-old advice about ignoring those who annoy you is still true!

Anonymous
Sun Feb 28 2010 19:33
This article isn't about men! Shope and Nittman could be girls, write the same garbage, and the response would still be necessary
Anonymous
Sun Feb 28 2010 12:47
This is turning into hedges+girls vs. boys. Game on!
NOT Thomas Hedges
Sun Feb 28 2010 12:02
YES YES I Agree COMPLETELY! You are so right about men! They are eVIL and DisguSTing and vile creatures! Peh peh! I spit on them all! You and Thomas Hedges are the most intelligent, awesome, brilliant, all-knowing, beautiful creatures on God's green earth! Especially Hedges, he's hot!
Anonymous
Fri Feb 26 2010 16:49
I BELIEVE EVERYTHING WRITTEN IN MINUS THE CITY AT FACE VALUE AND FOLLOW ITS MESSAGE AS LAW. MAT NITTMAN AND BEN SHOPE ARE MY GODS AND SEXUAL IDOLS.
Weezy F
Fri Feb 26 2010 08:12
Wow, its as if people like you and Thomas Hedges are trying to suck the fun out of this school bit-by-bit. How sad. At least his writing was good...
Anonymous
Fri Feb 26 2010 02:08
Get off your high horse. It's just for fun. People here have absolutely NO sense of humor. It's people like you that make the winter months longer for everyone else.
YM
Thu Feb 25 2010 14:50
(Idk why it did show up but I, Yasmin Mannan wrote the last comment)
Anonymous
Thu Feb 25 2010 14:39
I totally agree with you here and I would like to commend you for stepping up to the plate and saying something about this overtly offensive article. Although it was originally intended to be funny it did nothing but expose the ignorant and misogynistic mentalities of some of the males on Colgate’s campus. I can admit that I was originally upset when I read the article, but now that I look at it, perhaps it is a good thing that these views were brought to the forefront so that we can address them. It allows us to point out that the behavior endorsed in the article and other careless sexual acts are not healthy and will come at a consequence. Whether in the form of STD’s, heartbreak, emotional problems or overall dissatisfaction in relationships, reckless sexual behavior never has a happy ending. I’m sure Prince Charming knows nothing about what it means to live happily ever after but hopefully, one day, he’ll learn healthy sexual habits and will in turn not only treat Buttercup with more respect but have a better relationship with her in the long run.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 25 2010 14:13
I agree with everything said in this article. Great message, well done! Someone needed to say it!






log out